How to read the ratings, and what they miss
Stars are a flashlight, not a verdict. They help you see where to look more closely. Here is how I suggest families use them.
Start with what matters most to you
- Location. For a nursing home, being close enough for family to visit often matters more than a one-star difference. CMS says the same on its Five-Star page.
- The kind of care you need. Short-term rehab after a hospital stay is different from long-term care for dementia. Look at the short-stay or long-stay quality rating that fits.
- For hospice: whether they serve your address, how fast they can start, and how they handle nights and weekends.
Then look under the overall stars
- Nursing homes: read the actual inspection citations, especially any marked “actual harm” or “immediate jeopardy,” and check the staffing hours and turnover. A home can have a good overall rating while one domain is weak.
- Hospice: look at the individual family survey answers. A low score on “getting timely help” or “help for pain and symptoms” tells you what to ask about.
- Look at the trend. On each facility page I show the ratings across past CMS releases. One bad inspection can drop a rating; a pattern over years tells you more.
Know the limits
- The data are old. Hospice survey results cover deaths up to about two years before they are published. Nursing home staffing reflects one quarter of payroll data. Every chart on this site shows its period.
- “Not rated” is not bad. Small, new or rural providers often lack enough data for a rating.
- State comparison. Nursing home inspection stars compare homes within the same state.
- Methods change. CMS changed the inspection method in July 2025 and revised the hospice family survey in 2025. Some changes in ratings reflect method, not care.
For exactly how the scores are built, see How Medicare calculates the ratings.
Where this comes from
- CMS, Five-Star Quality Rating System page, page last modified October 27, 2026.
- CMS, “Design for Care Compare Nursing Home Five-Star Quality Rating System: Technical Users’ Guide”, September 2026.
- CAHPS® Hospice Survey, “Technical Notes for CAHPS Hospice Survey Star Ratings, August and November 2026”, 2026.